86 points Wine Spectator - April 1988

Has great Pinot Noir complexity and good structure. Fairly tannic, built on nice cherry, strawberry and cinnamon flavors. It feels velvety yet tastes austere and finishes slightly astringent. Could use one or two years’ cellaring.

The Underground Wine Journal  - December/January 1988

Dark in color, this wine has berry and cherry fruit aromas with some smokiness, vanilla and a very spicy essence. On the palate the taste is of tart, cherry/berry fruit with spice, vanilla and a smokiness and is somewhat light in the mouth. It has balanced acidity, moderate, balanced tannins and a long, lingering very slightly bitter, tart finish. One to lay away, it is a very intriguing, spicy wine that is somewhat tight and underdeveloped new and needs a few more years to come together. Mount Eden continues thier success in Chardonnay with this fine Pinot offering. 16 1/2 Very Good

Rating Scale for The Underground Wineletter:

18-20 Outstanding

15-17 Very good

12-14 Good

Under 12 Below Average

California Grapevine - October/November 1987

Medium ruby; attractive, rich, smokey “Burgundian” aroma with good concentration and depth of fruit and hints of coffee and sausage; medium-full body (12% alcohol); rich moderately concentrated fruit flavors on the palate with moderate tannin and a slightly harsh, tart, bitter finish; lingering aftertaste. We would have liked a bit more richness on the palate to compliment the rich, outstanding varietal character in the aroma. Score 16

Connoisseurs' Guide to California Wine - May 1988

Rating:

Concentrated, black cherry fruit is joined by lots of toasty oak and rich, loamy earth tones in the deep, moderately intense aromas and the wine accurately mirrors each of these elements in its dense, young, decidedly forceful flavors. Fairly full in body and very firm in structure with medium tannins lending noticeable astringency to the lengthy finish, this many-layered rendition should shed its youthful hardness and blossom beautifully in five years’ time.